Homeownership vs. Renting: Benefits and Downsides

SPONSORED CONTENT

Buying a home is an important goal for many Americans. But high prices and low inventory have been a deterrent for many buyers over the past few years. Renting has fewer maintenance costs and offers more flexibility, but it may not provide the stability that some people need.

While some may favor buying over renting, factors like cost, maintenance, flexibility, location and lifestyle are important considerations. Here are some of the advantages and disadvantages to bear in mind when you’re deciding whether to rent or buy.

Financial considerations

The costs associated with buying and renting are the key consideration for many people deciding which path to choose. While renting doesn’t buy you equity, it may be the more affordable choice in a hot real estate market. On the other hand, buying allows you to turn your monthly payments into equity and offers access to a financial asset.

Homeownership

Let’s start by considering the benefits and drawbacks of homeownership.

Benefits:

Buying a house offers important long and short-term benefits like the following.

• Build equity and wealth: Monthly mortgage payments aren’t like rent payments. While rent payments are income for your landlord, every mortgage payment buys you more equity in your home. You can leverage your home equity for cash through a cash-out refinance or home equity loan.

Additionally, owning a home can be a significant investment as property values often increase over time, contributing to personal wealth.

• Mortgage payments as forced savings: Monthly mortgage payments gradually pay off the home, increasing the owner’s equity. Though you lose cash monthly, you gain equity you can use later. In a competitive real estate market, you may be able to sell your home at a much higher price than you bought it for. So, your mortgage payments act as monthly savings or investments in an appreciating asset.
• Tax benefits: Homeowners may take advantage of various tax deductions, potentially lowering their overall tax burden. When you buy a house, you can take advantage of deductions on mortgage interest, mortgage points (also known as discount points), property taxes, eligible home improvements and mortgage insurance.

Downsides:

Buying a house also has some cons worth noting.

• Upfront costs: Purchasing a home requires substantial initial expenses, including down payments and closing costs. While down payments can vary based on your mortgage, you may need to put down 20% to avoid paying for mortgage insurance on conventional loans. You will also pay closing costs which range from 2% to 6% of the home’s price.
• Maintenance and repair expenses: Homeowners are responsible for all upkeep and repair costs, which can add up over time. Unseen issues often crop up when you finally move into a home. HVAC problems, leaky plumbing, landscaping, etc., can catch new homeowners off guard. It is important to plan for repairs and maintenance when buying a house.
• Property taxes, homeowner’s insurance, and other costs: Homeowners can also expect to pay property taxes and homeowner’s insurance when they buy a home (if they don’t put down more than 20% on conventional loans). Depending on where you live, you may have to pay extra for flood insurance, HOA fees, etc. These additional costs may be necessary and can vary significantly based on location and property value.

Renting

Renting may sound like the ideal solution for someone seeking flexibility and low payments. But these are the pros and cons to keep in mind.

Benefits:

The benefits of renting include:

• Lower upfront costs: The costs of renting typically include a security deposit and the first month’s rent – you will pay much less than the upfront costs you would pay to purchase a comparable property. Renters face fewer initial expenses compared to homebuyers.
• No responsibility for maintenance and repairs: Landlords typically handle property upkeep and repairs, reducing financial and time burdens for renters. Renters usually do not have to worry about leaky pipes, appliances breaking, or electrical issues. Repairs and maintenance are usually included in the rent.
• Flexibility to relocate easily: Renting allows for easier relocation, which is ideal for those with transient lifestyles or uncertain long-term plans.

Downsides:

The cons of renting are as follows:

• Rent payments don’t build equity: Monthly rent payments do not contribute to ownership or personal wealth accumulation. You are paying to live somewhere temporarily, but you have no long-term claim on the home.
• Subject to rent increases and lease terms: Renters may face rising costs and restrictions based on their lease agreements. This is one reason many people favor buying. As homes get expensive and inflation rises, rents may rise too.
• Limited control over property modifications: Renters usually cannot make significant changes to their living space without landlord approval. You may not be able to personalize your living space or transform the space to your liking.

Lifestyle and flexibility

Your living arrangement will significantly affect your lifestyle and day-to-day experience. Lifestyle preferences and needs play crucial roles in the homeownership versus renting decision. These personal considerations can influence long-term satisfaction and financial well-being. Here are some of the lifestyle aspects of owning and renting to consider.

Homeownership:

Lifestyle features of homeownership include:

• Stability and roots in a community: Owning a home often fosters a sense of stability and connection to a neighborhood. Some may become homeowners just before or after growing their family so their kids can grow up around friendly neighbors in a safe, close-knit community.
• Ability to customize and make long-term plans: Most homeowners have the freedom to modify their homes and make decisions with a long-term perspective. They can modernize or expand their home, add external features, and personalize their home as they wish. Some restrictions may apply in HOAs or planned neighborhoods.
• Potential to rent out or use home equity for investments: Homeowners can generate income by renting out their property or leveraging home equity for financial opportunities. Some homeowners purchase a second property with a jumbo loan so they can turn it into a rental home or vacation rental. Others may move out but hold on to their first home so they can rent it out.

Renting:

Here’s what you can expect as a renter:

• Flexibility: Renting allows for easy relocation, which can be beneficial for career advancements or personal changes. You don’t need to worry about the lengthy process of staging, listing, and selling your home when an opportunity calls you elsewhere. Terminating your lease is much faster and simpler, but can come with penalties depending on the terms of your lease.
• Less commitment and fewer ties to a specific location: Renters are not tied down by property ownership, providing greater freedom to move as desired. For example, if you are in a particular city for work but intend to move eventually, it makes sense to avoid the hassle of buying in your current city and renting instead.
• Ability to upgrade to better amenities easily: Renters can choose properties with better amenities without the long-term commitment of homeownership. It’s easy to end a rental agreement and move into a new rental property when you want to upgrade the size, style or location of your residence.

Looking at the market

Market conditions significantly impact the benefits and downsides of both homeownership and renting. Understanding market trends and regional variations is essential in making an informed decision.

Homeownership:

Here is what to consider if you are planning to buy:

• Market fluctuations: Home values can rise or fall based on market conditions, impacting homeowners’ equity. When home prices are sky-high, you may need an exceptionally good credit score, a large down payment, and funds to buy mortgage points to make your mortgage affordable.
• Long-term investment potential: Despite market volatility, real estate often provides substantial long-term returns. If you have the means, you can buy a house now and sell it in 5-7 years when you can turn a profit.
• Regional variations in housing market stability: Different regions experience varying levels of market stability and growth potential. You’ll need to keep up with property trends in your area or talk to a local real estate agent to understand what your local market looks like and if it makes sense to buy.

Renting:

These are the market consideration to remember if you are interested in renting:

• Renting costs may rise with market demand: High demand can drive up rental prices, affecting affordability. While renting may still be cheaper than buying, you may have to consider a more affordable location or suburb.
• Less exposure to market downturns: Renters are not directly impacted by property value decreases, offering some financial protection. You don’t need to worry about your property losing its value.
• Limited financial risk: Renting involves fewer financial risks related to market fluctuations and property devaluation compared to homeownership.

How to Decide

The decision to buy or rent will come down to your personal goals, finances, and local property market. Consider affordability and long-term financial implications, career plans, potential relocations, and the importance of flexibility versus stability. It is also a good idea to talk to experts like financial advisors, trustworthy real estate professionals, and mortgage lenders. Consider speaking to friends or family who are buying or renting in your desired neighborhood. With the right information and expertise, you will be able to make an informed decision.

Disclaimer: Article content is intended for information only. It may not reflect the publisher nor employees’ views. Consult a mortgage professional before making financial decisions. Publishers or platforms may be compensated for access to third party websites.

Contact Information:
Name: Sonakshi Murze
Email: [email protected]
Job Title: Manager